
← The Innovators Studio with Phil McKinney28 okt · 15 min
Mastering Critical Thinking in the Age of AI
I asked two AIs one question, and both missed their own future. That's a critical thinking problem for anyone who uses AI.
I asked them:
"Take a look at consumer electronics and identify the top five unsolved problems that could become disruptions if a solution could be found." Here's what came back. Grok saw problems to fix, like phones built so you can't repair them. Claude saw opportunities to build, like AR glasses you'd wear all day.
Same question, two different ways of seeing the industry, and each one read like the final answer.
With AI, critical thinking comes down to three checks. And later, I'll have one of these AIs argue against my own pick. It landed a couple of punches.
Let's get into it.
Check 1: Cross-Check With a Second AI In my first video on critical thinking skills, one of the first steps was to cross-reference your sources. It still works. With AI, you cross-reference by asking a second AI the same question. Then read the two answers three ways.
Where they overlap, you have a stronger signal. Battery was number one on both lists. That's the one I'd look at first.
Where they split, your judgment starts.
Grok: repair, software that kills devices, heat that limits on-device AI, and devices that won't connect. Claude: AR glasses, health sensing, memory costs, and trust in always-on devices. Both lists are defensible. Deciding which matters is your job.
What's missing from both is the blind spot. That's where your own experience counts most.
Here's what I'd have put on the list: agents that reliably act for you.