
← The Power Of Zero Show21 okt · 11 min
The Retirement Problem No One Can Solve? Not So Fast.
Financial planning expert Rob Berger says the biggest challenge in retirement planning is one that no one can solve, since nobody knows how long retirement will last.
David McKnight shares his disagreement, and explains why a financial product designed for exactly this problem – annuities – may be the answer.
Show Notes In this episode, David McKnight responds to Rob Berger's video The Retirement Problem No One Can Solve.
Rob compares retirement to entering a race without knowing how long it is, how fast you can safely run, or when someone will tell you that you've reached the finish line.
David thinks Rob did an excellent job of identifying the problem, but he strongly disagrees with the premise that no one can solve it.
The fundamental challenge for every retiree is that you don't know whether your savings will need to support you for five, twenty-five years, or longer than that.
David shares a different analogy, inspired by retirement economist Michael Finke: a birthday party with one large cake and no idea how many children will show up.
The cake is the pool of money you've accumulated, the children are the years you'll live after retiring, and the slices are your annual retirement income.
If you cut the cake into thirty tiny pieces just in case, and only five children show up, everyone gets an unnecessarily small piece and most of the cake goes uneaten – that's traditional retirement planning.
You ration your savings as though you might live to 95, 100, or beyond, and if you die earlier than expected, you leave behind a very large portfolio because you were afraid to spend your money.
According to David, Rob is wrong in saying that no one can solve this problem, as annuities were literally invented to solve it.
Imagine a bakery promising to keep delivering more cake if you run out. You've transferred your longevity risk to the bakery, which is what an insurance company does.