unSeminary Podcast

← unSeminary Podcast12 nov · 42 min

500 Volunteers in a Church of 1,300: How Community Did It with Lou Pizzichillo

500 Volunteers in a Church of 1,300: How Community Did It with Lou Pizzichillo12 nov42 min

Welcome back to another episode of the unSeminary podcast. We’re talking with Lou Pizzichillo, Lead Pastor of Community Church in Babylon, New York. Today, Community Church welcomes roughly 1,200 to 1,300 people, with more than 500 actively serving on volunteer teams. Lou is also the founder of TeamFit, a volunteer placement tool that grew directly out of what Community Church has learned about helping people find meaningful places to serve.

How do you create a volunteer culture where people genuinely want to serve? What if the key isn’t simply recruiting more people, but helping them feel known, appreciated, and connected to a shared mission? Tune in as Lou shares how Community Church builds strong volunteer teams, reinforces culture, and removes the mystery from serving.

Unite people around a shared goal. // From the earliest days of Community Church, serving was part of the church’s DNA. Before launch, volunteers worked together to renovate an unexpected meeting space in just two weeks. After COVID, the church repeated the process while rebuilding its team. Lou discovered that working toward something meaningful together creates connection, ownership, and a sense that everyone is winning as one team.

Define the win clearly. // Lou believes churches often assume volunteers understand what success looks like in their role. Community Church works hard to turn unspoken expectations into memorable language. Phrases such as “relational before spiritual” help volunteers understand how the church approaches people, while “black shirts stand shoulder to shoulder, not face to face” reminds guest services volunteers to remain open and attentive to newcomers.

Repeat culture constantly. // Values are communicated through several rhythms. Lou sends monthly team updates that include church news and a featured value. Before every service, volunteers attend a 15-minute huddle where leaders reinforce values and tell stories. The church also uses Slack to share wins and celebrate examples of people living out the culture. Repetition turns values from slogans into everyday behavior.

Celebrate what you want repeated. // Community Church intentionally highlights volunteer wins because what you celebrate, you’ll replicate. Stories are shared in huddles, online, and through fun recognition such as a rotating team member of the week award. Celebration gives volunteers concrete examples of what success looks like while reinforcing that their contribution matters.

Lead with