Weight and Healthcare

← Weight and Healthcare26 sep · 8 min

Hernia Repair and Higher-Weight People Part 2 - The Realities of Requiring Weight Loss

Hernia Repair and Higher-Weight People Part 2 - The Realities of Requiring Weight Loss26 sep8 min

This is the Weight and Healthcare newsletter! If you like what you are reading, please consider subscribing and/or sharing!

In Part 1 we discussed the basics of hernia repair for higher-weight people. In part 3 we’ll discuss the options for fighting BMI-based denials for hernia care. While I take the stance that people of all sizes deserve equitable care, in Part 2, I want to talk about the issues with these weight loss recommendations (this is a piece I’ve been meaning to write for a while so I’m incuding it in this series, but know that this isn’t just about hernia repair but about anytime weight loss is recommended or required for a patient to be “optimized” for surgery.) Today we’re going to look at it from the perspective of someone who agrees with these recommendations (which I d not) and/or of somene who is so desperate for care that they are willing to try to pay the weight loss ransom (which is a valid choice, but one that patients should never be coerced into making by a healthcare system that holds their care hostage.) Even in these circumstances, there are multiple issues with these weight loss recommendations including feasibility, side effects, and long-term prognosis.

Feasibility and Side Effects

The first question to ask is the feasibility of the requirement. “Optimization” for surgery doesn’t happen in a vacuum and it doesn’t matter if something would make the patient’s surgery easier or improve their outcomes if it is not possible and/or if it harms the patient more than it helps them. Despite this, the feasibility/likelihood of the patient experiencing the required weight loss is, in my experience, far too often not discussed or even considered.

I have met with patients who were told they needed to lose 40% of their body weight whose surgeon told them to eat less and exercise more. This is an “intervention” for which about a century of research has found the likelihood of losing even 5% of body weight is quite low and the likelihood of maintaining it is incredibly small (though we’ll get to that.) The doctor might as well have told the patient to grow 6 inches to change their BMI sufficiently.

Enter GLP-1s. Here again we’re seeing patients being prescribed these drugs not based on the drugs’ actual capacity to create (at least short term) the required weight loss but based on the sincerely held personal belief of the provider that any amount of weight can be lost with these drugs.

In the recent research article that Angela Meadows, Louis